InTune

13 Responses to “Vote today! Three Contest Entries, Only One Will Win!”

1. 

   robin
   

   Nov 04, 2008

   Performer A sounds a little choppy and plays the whole song at the same speed. Performer B is too long and repeats itself over and over again. Performer C shows a little more style

   Reply to this comment
2. 

   Geman
   

   Nov 09, 2008

   I saw the hands of the Performer A and looks like he was pressing the correct keys.

   However, Performer C looks like the music was played in a computer and he mute the piano speaker pretending he was playing with his own hand.

   Performance B played too slow.

   Reply to this comment
3. 

   Janet
   

   Nov 09, 2008

   Artist A looks as though he is enjoying his performance.
   Artist B is playing too slow, and needs improvment, was he reading the music as he was playing?
   Artist C. Was the sound out of time? he looks as though he is not in control or is the computer playing for him.

   Reply to this comment
4. 

   Johnson
   

   Nov 09, 2008

   Artist A does a great job truly playing this piece of work.

   I just can’t get into this particular piece done on the guitar – sorry, but it is a noble attempt.

   Artist C is “finger-synching” – he is definitely not playing this!!

   Reply to this comment
5. 

   shelly
   

   Nov 09, 2008

   The defects in these videos is no different than what happens during a fox news broadcast

   Reply to this comment
6. 

   linda
   

   Nov 10, 2008

   performer A at 50 seconds into his video looks like he SPLICED two separate performances together

   Reply to this comment
7. 

   Grace
   

   Nov 10, 2008

   As he notes on the You Tube site, performer C played the keyboards into a computer to keep the sound clean, which it is. Anyone whose made videos this way would realize that lose of a few video frames occurs unless you have high end proceeses to mesh the video and audio together. Try it.

   Reply to this comment
8. 

   debra
   

   Nov 17, 2008

   based on 196 votes. total weighed votes performer A 636, preformer C 657

   Reply to this comment
9. 

   Monica
   

   Nov 18, 2008

   Hi Debra, per the rules the winner would not be based on the amount of people who voted but decided from a combination of this poll, the YouTube ratings from the public, our internal decision and the quality of the performance.

   Based on our previous experiences with contests, when we created the rules we felt that just basing the content award on the number of votes alone would potentially create challenges with the integrity of the contest.

   Thank you everyone for your comments! You’ve all made this first month’s contest a success!

   Reply to this comment
10. 

    alex
    

    Nov 18, 2008

    Congratulations to performer C.

    Reply to this comment
11. 

    Monica
    

    Nov 18, 2008

    Thanks for your comment, Alex. I’m sorry if I misled our musiclovers today, but we have not yet announced the winner. That will happen very shortly; the head of our team would like to say a few words.

    Reply to this comment
12. 

    MARY SOILEX
    

    Dec 29, 2008

    number three is mein favorite,,,but i ll tell ya….number two was a blast und number one had excitement

    but they all played some wrong notes…and some were fakers

    i wish i hearda real piano..those leyboards dunt do it for me

    but bravo meistros und keep up teh good work. yull get to teh carnegie hall someday..if i know mine onions,

    Reply to this comment
13. 

    Leona
    

    Mar 24, 2009

    first of all, i have never heard this song before so not sure of how it should sound
    First performer i thought was very good, showed enthusian in his playing of the piano
    second performer on the guitar, i thought was horrible, notes very repeatitive
    third performer, did not even look at the piano to see where
    the keys were, looked like the piano was programmed to play this song

    Reply to this comment